Valerie Spencer

To Jeff’s (Patrick Warburton) enjoyment, Audrey’s (Megyn Price) throat surgery leaves her speechless. Adam (Oliver Hudson) tries to convince everyone that he has more going for him than just his good looks. Timmy (Adhir Kalyan) uses another job offer as leverage after being forced by Russell (David Spade) to fire a coworker.

Josh and Raquel attempt domestic bliss in the Pfefferman house by asking Colton to move in. Maura takes Ali to UCLA to discuss graduate school where they meet feminist scholar, Leslie Mackinaw – Maura's old nemesis. Sarah has a run-in with Len and Barb, and begins a sexual fantasy life with a domineering figure from her past.

Maura revisits the night that Ali was born. Davina recalls memories of her youth and comes to terms with her troubled relationship with Sal. Davina and Maura each make a deal with God.