Julanne Chidi Hill

Lilly examines a 1979 murder investigation after a woman hands her a home video filmed by her perverted husband, which appears to show a teenage runaway being shot and killed.

Bitter towards karma after his release from prison, Earl reverts to his old criminal ways. However, karma catches up to him in the shape of a car and Billie.

Nancy wants to move her business while working the shop, so she enquires about it to all her former Agrestic people to see what they can move.

Earl turns his attention to his Karma list after listening to his friends' romantic advice. Along the way, he realises that atoning for his past mistakes is bringing about a change in Billie.

Jerry tries to get a continuance in order to give a woman the chance to help her son complete his college applications before she goes to prison.

Billie believes Earl is spending more time with his list than with her, and retaliates by undoing each of his good deeds in a bid to get his attention.