99 Problems

S5, E17: Outnumbered by demons, Sam and Dean are saved at the last minute by a hunter named Rob (guest star Michael Shanks) and his townspeople – all of them aware of the Apocalypse and trained to fight and kill demons. The small town is very religious and Sam and Dean meet Pastor Gideon (guest star Larry Poindexter), who introduces them to his daughter Leah (guest star Kayla Mae Maloney), whom he claims is a prophet. Leah tells the townspeople they must obey her orders if they want a spot in Heaven – but when she starts turning the townspeople against each other in the name of the Lord, the brothers realize they must kill her.