Amy Tolsky

Things get worse for the defendant.

Max and Caroline host a grand opening celebration at their new cupcake shop. To show off her success, Max invites her former flameJohnny (recurring guest star NICK ZANO) and her ex-boyfriend Robbie (recurring guest star NOAH MILLS). Recurring guest star RYANHANSEN appears as Caroline's love interest, Andy.

Desperate for a way to pay their overdue rent, Max and Caroline get involved with a group of sketchy customers willing to pay topdollar for their cupcakes. Recurring guest star RYAN HANSEN appears as Andy.

When Dr. Kelso (Ken Jenkins) challenges the residents by offering a trip to a medical conference in Reno as a reward to the individual that presents the most interesting cast study J.D. (Zach Braff) refuses to play along earning him the respect of Dr. Cox (John C. McGinley). However when Elliot (Sarah Chalke) confronts him about the competition he realizes that it was in fact his fear of failure rather than his rebellious nature that kept him out of the running. Following some awkward moments and harsh words Elliot and Carla (Judy Reyes) learn they have more in common than the just their relationships with J.D. and Turk (Donald Faison) bringing them closer together. In the meantime Turk misses his opportunity to ask for a new laser on the one day a year that Dr. Kelso grants favors so he is forced to find another way to come up with the goods. Neil Flynn also stars.

Leslie is overwhelmed when she and Andy visit Ben and April in Washington, D.C.; Ron throws a barbecue for the whole staff.

When Ron hexes the day to prove superstitions aren't real, things at the hospital start getting weird; Joyce and Matt discover an employee's secret.