My Killer Father: The Green Hollow Murders

After alleging that her father killed dozens of women and forced her and her siblings to help hide the bodies, Lucy Studey McKiddy returns to Green Hollow to tell her story; her sister Susan insists it's all a lie and fiercely defends their father, while other family members come forward in support of Lucy, including her three step-sisters, who recount years of violence and share a belief that their mother was murdered.

Early officers' accounts hint at a cover-up in Charlotte's death; a pattern in Don Studey's past emerges, and a re-autopsy reveals more. Don had five wives: all accused him of abuse; three are dead, two ruled suicides. As the children of his wives and the original responding officers come forward, Charlotte's body is exhumed for a new autopsy, raising new questions about her death.

For the first time, Lucy is given access to the property where she says the bodies were hidden; a five-day excavation begins, as investigators search for the wells she has described for years; a former FBI agent and a renowned forensic pathologist reexamine Charlotte's death, reconstructing the scene and working to determine a definitive cause.